An ice cream sandwich is a frozen confection composed of a layer of ice cream (usually vanilla) sandwiched between two soft wafers (usually chocolate). This dessert has become a running gag usually based around Matt and Woolie retreating to Matt's apartment for the salvation of the tasty summer treat. They made their debut in the Machinima episode of Blood Dragon where Woolie only brought them in hopes of getting to play the game, but after running out Pat told him to fuck off, with Matt reasoning that Woolie must have just gotten hungry on the way over.
- Pat and Liam have yet to eat them on camera, but Pat was seen helping Matt restock after E3.
- During the X-Men Next Dimension video Matt is seen taking his ice cream sandwich into the bathroom for what he called "multi-tasking".
- Matt has replied that the reason they keep mentioning and showcasing ice cream sandwiches is because they're hoping for a sponsorship. Another possible reason is that they're delicious.